Essay

The unintentional winner

By Michael Becker 

I hate los­ing. I don’t hate it so much as I used to, but then again, I don’t lose often now, so it’s hard to say whether my reac­tion to los­ing has soft­ened over the years or whether I just enjoy the nov­elty of los­ing from time to time.Please don’t take this the wrong way. I’m not brag­ging. Nei­ther am I try­ing to be a dick. I just hap­pen to win at a lot of games. Scrab­ble, rummy, chess, video games, dice, cross­word puz­zles — com­pet­ing against oth­ers, com­pet­ing against the clock, com­pet­ing against myself. I just tend toward the win col­umn. There’s no real expla­na­tion for it.

Well, there might be. Some peo­ple in this fine life of mine, the ones who refuse to play me at some games because of my sup­pos­edly innate skill, tell me that I’m a nat­ural at games, that some­thing in my brain picks out the nec­es­sary plays and strate­gies needed to win, even if I only just learned the rules.

Case in point: Years ago I went with my fam­ily to the house of a fam­ily friend for a hol­i­day evening. They intro­duced me to the game Rum­mikub. For those of you who’ve never played, it’s sort of a cross between rummy and domi­noes. I’d seen the game in the store before, but it was always in that sort of lame adult-oriented, card-game sec­tion that I never paid atten­tion to while lust­ing after my own copy of “Axis & Allies” or “Risk.”

I lost the first few hands of the game, but then some­thing hap­pened. I started win­ning. Not only that, but I started win­ning quickly and deci­sively, not just a hand here or there, but all of them. All of them. It was weird, and I don’t think any­one has played me at that game since.

You see, there are prob­lems with win­ning. First of all, you could be a poor win­ner — I’m not, or at least don’t think I’m a poor win­ner. The poor win­ners are those who obnox­iously rub their vic­to­ries in the faces of their defeated foes. You could call these peo­ple brag­garts, but a more apt descrip­tion would be to call them assholes.

There are the unin­ten­tion­ally poor win­ners, who don’t real­ize that they are act­ing supe­rior after a win. The nam­ing of these peo­ple as “poor win­ners” usu­ally has less to do with their own asshol­ish behav­ior than it has to do with the atti­tude of the per­son they’ve just beaten. Usu­ally the unin­ten­tion­ally poor win­ner is declared so by an unknow­ingly poor loser.

I don’t think I’m often an unin­ten­tion­ally poor win­ner, but I do think that a third issue with win­ning does apply to me: acci­den­tal impoliteness.

You see, games are not only com­pe­ti­tion. They are social inter­ac­tion. When you win over and over again, you vio­late a social more. You offend other peo­ple with what appears to be your focus on com­pe­ti­tion, rather than on the social nature of the game. The con­stant win­ner doesn’t allow for the game’s nat­ural rhythms to take hold. There’s no give and take, no back and forth, no true “play.” Just a one-sided deal that’s raw for all but one player.

In such a sit­u­a­tion, the win­ner — who may be win­ning acci­den­tally, innately or pur­pose­fully — becomes an unde­sir­able, unwel­come. The win­ner is pushed from the social cir­cle so that the focus of the game can return to con­ver­sa­tion and good times, rather than what it can only focus on when the win­ner is play­ing: “Why the hell does that guy always have to win?”

Usu­ally this means that the win­ner is not invited back for game night, or the oth­ers grum­ble about him behind his back (or to his face). In my case, this amounts to not being able to play games with the peo­ple I know because they just refuse the chal­lenge outright.

I’m sorry I win so much. I’m not being face­tious. I really am sorry. It’s not my fault, and it would be even more demean­ing to myself and to every­body else involved if I were to throw a few games just to make it inter­est­ing. So please, every­one, accept this hum­ble apol­ogy and play me at games again. Please?

About the author

Michael Becker escaped alive after three years as a beat reporter for the Bozeman Daily Chronicle and wound up, somehow, writing about engineering for Montana State University.

Read more from Michael Becker.


blog comments powered by Disqus

This text was written in response to the Winning and Losing nudge and was published on January 19, 2009.